About FirstChoice Agent Match

The right agent
changes everything.

Your home is likely the biggest financial decision you’ll ever make. Yet most people choose their agent from an ad, a quick search, or a name someone sold to them. We built something better: a real person who listens first, then connects you with an agent who truly fits.

Antonia Sevilla, founder of FirstChoice Agent Match

A letter from the founder

Hi, I’m Antonia.

I’ve spent my career in client service, business operations, and building tools that make complicated things simple. Through all of it, one truth kept showing up: the right relationship can change someone’s entire experience.

Few relationships matter more than the one you have with your real estate agent. They guide your price, your negotiation, your timing — and often, your peace of mind. Still, the industry asks you to choose them almost blindly, while your information gets sold to the highest bidder.

I started FirstChoice Agent Match to change that. Here, your needs come first. I take the time to understand your goals, then personally introduce you to someone with the experience to deliver on them.

Because choosing your agent should feel like an informed decision — never a gamble.

— Antonia Sevilla

Founder, FirstChoice Agent Match · Licensed Real Estate Salesperson | SPiRALNY

Text Antonia directly

The FirstChoice standard

Great agents aren’t right for everyone.

A first-time buyer, a luxury seller, and a family relocating across the country need very different guidance. That’s why we match on fit.

Advocacy over algorithms

Every request is read by Antonia — a licensed professional — not sorted by software and auctioned to whoever pays most.

Fit over availability

We look at the markets an agent truly knows, the deals they actually close, and how they communicate. Not who happens to be free.

Your privacy, protected

Your number is never sold or passed down a lead list. Your details go to one carefully chosen introduction — that’s it.

You stay in control

An introduction is never a contract. Interview, ask hard questions, and only move forward when it feels right.

Who we help

One connection can make all the difference.

Buying a home

Whether it’s your first place, a cross-country move, or your next investment, you deserve a guide who knows the streets — not just the listings. Need financing help? We can introduce you to a trusted local lender.

Find My Buyer’s Agent

Selling a home

Pricing, presentation, and negotiation decide what you walk away with. We introduce you to agents with real, recent results in your market.

Find My Listing Agent

For agents

Licensed professionals who put clients first can join a referral network built on clear expectations and genuine relationships.

Join Our Agent Network

Simple by design

From first message to first meeting.

01

Share your story

Tell us where you’re moving, your timeline, and what matters most. It takes about two minutes.

02

Antonia does the homework

She reviews your goals against agents’ local experience, track record, and working style.

03

Meet your match

You get a warm, personal introduction — not a flood of calls from strangers.

04

Decide with confidence

You choose whether to work together. No pressure, no obligation, no cost.

Our mission

Better connections. Better moves.

To make finding the right real estate agent personal, transparent, and free for every buyer and seller in America — so no one has to guess who to trust with their biggest decision.

Straight answers

Questions we hear often.

Is it really free?

Yes — completely. Buyers and sellers never pay FirstChoice anything to be matched.

Can you help outside New York?

Absolutely. We match buyers and sellers with agents in all 50 states, including people relocating between states.

Do I have to use the agent you introduce?

Never. You’re free to meet them, compare, and decide. If it isn’t the right fit, just tell Antonia.

Are you a brokerage?

FirstChoice is an agent matching and referral service. Your transaction is handled by the licensed agent and brokerage you choose.

So how do you get paid?

Where permitted, the receiving brokerage pays a referral fee after a successful closing. You are never charged for the match.

Your next move starts with the right connection.

A better match. A smarter move. Always free.